Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

2022 Attorneys of the Year: State of Minnesota v. Stevenson

Dan Emerson//February 16, 2023

From left: Arielle Wagner, Kate Baxter-Kauf, Kristen Marttila

From left: Arielle Wagner, Kate Baxter-Kauf, Kristen Marttila

2022 Attorneys of the Year: State of Minnesota v. Stevenson

Dan Emerson//February 16, 2023

The successful overturn of a conviction is rare, especially for pro bono attorneys. But a team of Lockridge Grindal Nauen lawyers accomplished that in 2022.

In State v. Stevenson, associate Arielle Wagner and LGN partners Kate Baxter-Kauf and Kristen G. Marttila successfully litigated a pro bono criminal appeal by a client who was unlawfully detained by police.

In 2020, after defendant Antonio Stevenson’s car was pulled over in Hennepin County, he was arrested, charged and convicted of giving a false name to an officer.

The LGN attorneys won a reversal of Stevenson’s criminal conviction by arguing that a sheriff’s deputy unconstitutionally expanded the scope of a traffic stop by opening the defendant’s car door, without “individualized, reasonable and articulable suspicion.”

Working for the Minnesota State Bar Association’s Public Defenders Appellate Pro Bono Program, Wagner, Baxter-Kauf and Marttila took on the case in mid-2021. Wagner argued and principally authored the brief; Baxter-Kauf supervises the appellate criminal pro bono practice at Lockridge Grindal Nauen and was involved in research, writing and editing the brief; and Marttila was instrumental in research, editing and argument preparation.

Minnesota courts had not previously ruled on the issue before the state Court of Appeals: whether an officer’s act of opening a car door without knocking or otherwise announcing himself after a routine citation violation requires separate justification as an expanded seizure. The overturn of Stevenson’s conviction provided “needed clarity to officers and the public regarding what constitutes a reasonable stop-and-seizure practice,” Wagner said.

Wagner said the ruling affirmed that police “can’t expand the scope of a traffic stop without articulable justification. It was a victory for individual rights and hopefully will help protect Minnesotans from these kinds of unconstitutional searches in the future.

“We’ve been working with this program for a number of years, and this was the first time we were successful in having a client’s conviction overturned.”

Wagner, who joined the firm in 2017, said the case was “a great learning experience. When I was a newer associate, I didn’t have many chances to work with a case and do full briefing and oral arguments, so it was a good experience for me.”

In her everyday work, Wagner spends most of her time handling plaintiffs’ class action work, “which is very different from doing a criminal matter,” she noted.

Read more about Minnesota Lawyer’s superb class of Attorneys of the Year for 2022 here.

Top News

See All Top News

Legal calendar

Click here to see upcoming Minnesota events

Expert Testimony

See All Expert Testimony