Quantcast
Home / All News / Court sends PolyMet air permit back to MPCA
closed LTV Steel taconite plant
In this Feb. 10, 2016, file photo, the closed LTV Steel taconite plant sits idle near Hoyt Lakes, Minnesota. It would become part of a proposed PolyMet copper-nickel mine. (AP file photo)

Court sends PolyMet air permit back to MPCA

Ruling says MPCA hadn’t sufficiently justified granting permit

The proposed PolyMet copper-nickel mine in northern Minnesota encountered a setback Monday when the state Court of Appeals ordered regulators to revisit a critical air emissions permit given to the project.

The court ruled that the Minnesota Pollution Control Agency hadn’t sufficiently justified granting the permit after opponents raised allegations that PolyMet was planning a much larger mine.

Environmental groups and a Native American tribe pointed to a report that PolyMet filed with Canadian regulators that suggested PolyMet was considering expanding the mine to four times the size that the air permit would allow.

The appeals court last year said the MPCA hadn’t adequately evaluated whether the air permit understated the company’s real plans, only to have that ruling overturned by the Minnesota Supreme Court. The high court ruled in February that the MPCA wasn’t required by federal law to investigate the allegations of “sham permitting.”

The Supreme Court sent the case back to the Court of Appeals to consider whether the agency correctly concluded that PolyMet would comply with all terms of the permit, and whether PolyMet had failed to fully disclose all relevant facts or submitted false or misleading information to the agency.

Monday’s ruling said the MPCA “has not adequately explained the reasons for its conclusions” and said that would be sufficient grounds to reverse the permit. But the court instead sent it back to the MPCA for reconsideration.

PolyMet issued a statement saying it’s disappointed in the court’s decision and “will expeditiously provide the supporting explanation requested by the court.” The company said the facts and the science prove that the project can meet state and federal air quality standards.

The open pit mine and processing plant near Babbitt and Hoyt Lakes would be Minnesota’s first copper-nickel mine. Environmentalists have fought the project because of the potential for acid mine drainage upstream from Lake Superior. The opponents are a coalition of groups led by the Minnesota Center for Environmental Advocacy plus the Fond du Lac Band of Lake Superior Chippewa.

The case is one of several legal challenges still making their way through the courts and regulatory agencies at the state and federal level that have led to suspensions, remands or reversals of important permits. The Minnesota Supreme Court in April affirmed the Court of Appeals’ reversal of PolyMet’s critical “permit to mine” and sent that case back to the state Department of Natural Resources for more proceedings.

“PolyMet has been speaking out of both sides of its mouth, trying to keep its plans for a bigger, dirtier mine hidden from the people of Minnesota,” Chris Knopf, executive director of the Friends of the Boundary Waters Wilderness, said in a statement. “Now, Governor (Tim) Walz and his administration has an opportunity to look at all the facts and science behind this toxic and dangerous proposal.”

 

Like this article? Gain access to all of our great content with a month-to-month subscription. Start your subscription.

About The Associated Press

Leave a Reply